Episode 15
What Is 1031 Exchange 'Boot' and Why Does It Trigger Taxes?
September 1, 2026 · 00:59:00
Real estate investors assume a 1031 exchange automatically shields them from capital gains taxes, but Bernard Reisz explains how easy it is to blow the deferral without realizing it. He unpacks "boot" — the taxable cash or value that leaks out when an investor pulls out a little cash at closing or trades into a slightly cheaper replacement property — and why these small, seemingly harmless decisions can quietly generate a tax bill investors thought they'd avoided entirely.
Bernard also reframes how investors should think about exchanges in the first place: a 1031 exchange should be evaluated as an investment strategy first, and a tax strategy second. Chasing the tax deferral without a sound underlying investment thesis is itself a common and expensive mistake. Listeners will come away understanding the mechanics of boot, the traps that catch even experienced investors off guard, and how to approach exchange decisions with the right priorities in mind. It's a useful primer for anyone who owns investment real estate and expects to sell — or exchange — in the future, before they find themselves surprised by a tax bill at closing.
Full show notes
Real estate investors lose the tax deferral of a 1031 exchange more often than they realize — sometimes just by pulling out a little cash or buying a slightly cheaper property. Bernard Reisz breaks down what a 1031 exchange actually is, how "boot" quietly creates a tax bill even when you think you did everything right, and why he treats it as an investment strategy first, tax strategy second.
Guest Links: Connect with Bernard Reisz
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/bernard-reisz-cpa
- Website: http://www.resurefinancial.com
- Email: bernard@resurefinancial.com
- 1031 Timeline Calculator: https://www.resurefinancial.com/1031-exchange-timeline-calculator/
- Blog post: https://members.resurefinancial.com/posts/exchange-is-not-a-tax-strategy
- Blog post: https://members.resurefinancial.com/posts/must-know-up-front-1031-exchange-issues
- Blog post: https://members.resurefinancial.com/posts/if-you-see-something-say-something-about-1031
- Blog post: https://members.resurefinancial.com/posts/throw-your-1031-in-the-bin
- Blog post: https://members.resurefinancial.com/posts/exchange-faqs
Top advice from this episode
-
A 1031 exchange should be viewed primarily as an investment strategy, because preserving $100,000 in taxes allows you to leverage bank financing to acquire $400,000 in new real estate.
-
You cannot execute a 1031 exchange if your property has already been sold; you must establish the exchange and engage a qualified intermediary before the closing to integrate the transactions for tax purposes.
-
If the money from a real estate sale is made available to you at any point, you are in "constructive receipt" of the funds and are immediately liable for the taxes, voiding the 1031 exchange.
-
Even if your replacement property falls through and your 1031 exchange fails, the fact that your funds were legally restricted pushes the gain recognition into the following tax year, effectively acting as a powerful installment sale.
Show 1 more
-
By continually utilizing 1031 exchanges throughout your life, you can defer all capital gains until you pass away, at which point your heirs receive a basis step-up that completely erases the accumulated tax liability.
FAQs
What is the 45-day rule in a 1031 exchange?
The 45-day rule is the identification deadline within a 1031 exchange. You have 45 days from the sale of your property to officially identify the potential replacement properties you intend to buy, using rules like the three-property rule or the 200% value rule.
Can I take cash out during a 1031 exchange?
Yes, you can execute a partial exchange and pull some cash out at the time of the sale, but every dollar you extract will be taxed as capital gains. Importantly, you must extract this money before it hits the restricted exchange account; otherwise, asking for the funds later will trigger constructive receipt and void the entire exchange.
What happens if my 1031 exchange replacement property falls through?
If your replacement property falls through after the 45-day identification period, your funds will remain locked up until the full 180-day exchange period expires. Because you did not have access to the money, the failed exchange effectively acts as an installment sale, successfully deferring your tax liability into the following calendar year.
Still Building with Ami
Don't miss the next one
Get a heads-up when new episodes drop, plus the extra stuff that doesn't make it into the show — in the newsletter.