Episode 06
Is Your Business Insurance Actually Enough to Cover a Claim?
April 15, 2026 · 01:13:58
Insurance paperwork is full of terms that sound interchangeable but aren't — and nowhere is that more dangerous than the difference between "actual cash value" and "replacement cost." In this episode, Jacob Fischman of GNP Insurance Brokerage breaks down how choosing the wrong one can leave a business owner holding a fraction of what they need to rebuild after a fire, storm, or theft, and why most people don't find out until it's too late to fix.
Jacob also walks through two other blind spots that catch business owners off guard: hiring uninsured subcontractors, which can shift full liability for an injury or accident straight onto the general contractor, and workplace harassment claims, which can still land on an employer even after the offending employee has been fired. Together, these examples paint a picture of insurance not as a box to check, but as a system that has to be understood in advance — because by the time a claim happens, it's too late to renegotiate the terms. Anyone who owns a business, manages contractors, or has employees will walk away with specific questions to ask their broker before their next renewal.
Full show notes
"Actual cash value" and "replacement cost" sound similar — the difference between them can bankrupt a business after a claim. Jacob Fischman (GNP Insurance Brokerage) covers the coverage gaps business owners don't know to ask about, why uninsured subcontractors put liability directly on the general contractor, and how workplace harassment claims can land on you even after firing the person responsible.
Guest Links: Connect with Jacob Fischman
- Phone: 347.451.4225
- Email: jacob@gnpbrokerage.com
- LinkedIn: Jacob Fischman | LinkedIn
- Website: www.gnpbrokerage.com
Top advice from this episode
-
General contractors must thoroughly read their subcontractors' policies to check for fine-print limitations, like height restrictions, which can void coverage during an accident.
-
Small businesses are prime targets for wire fraud and ransomware, making cyber insurance an inexpensive but critical safety net.
-
Cheaper property insurance policies often use "Actual Cash Value," which depreciates your assets and limits your payout, instead of "Replacement Cost," which covers the full price to replace the item.
-
Lying about your gross sales or payroll to get a cheaper insurance premium will backfire when the carrier performs an end-of-year audit and bills you for the discrepancy at a higher rate.
FAQs
What is the difference between general liability and professional liability insurance?
General liability protects you from third-party claims like a pedestrian getting injured by your work or property damage resulting from your product. Professional liability protects you if a client sues you over the fiduciary advice, errors, or omissions you provided in a professional capacity, such as a doctor or a broker.
What does EPLI insurance cover?
Employer's Professional Liability Insurance (EPLI) protects business owners from their own employees. It covers lawsuits and claims related to racism, prejudice, wrongful termination, wage disputes, or workplace abuse.
How do insurance companies calculate commercial policy premiums?
Insurance carriers underwrite policies based on either your gross sales or your total payroll. The more revenue you generate or the more employees you have on the job site, the higher the perceived risk is for the carrier, which dictates your rate.
Still Building with Ami
Don't miss the next one
Get a heads-up when new episodes drop, plus the extra stuff that doesn't make it into the show — in the newsletter.